Alliance Support Group


ARCHIVES: For older news items, please visit the news archives.

70pc of church fund used up for abuse cases in just two dioceses

Added on March 30, 2005


Wednesday March 30th 2005

THE central fund set up by the Catholic bishops to compensate abuse victims and pay for child protection services may be radically restructured as concerns grow in the hierarchy that it is not working as intended.

There are concerns that some dioceses are drawing on the trust to a disproportionate extent, resulting in a potentially unfair financial drain on other dioceses.

The Stewardship Trust established in 1996 received a ?10m cash injection from Church & General, the Church's insurer. That money has all but run out, meaning the trust is now funded directly by the 26 dioceses, with ?5m a year.

Sources in the hierarchy have told the Irish Independent of growing concerns on how the trust is run.

While the trust has to date paid ?8,781,592 to dioceses to help with compensation payments, ?6.22m of this, or 70pc, has gone to just two dioceses, Dublin and Ferns. Dioceses are paying into the fund according to their share of the Catholic population.

If this trend continues, it could mean that dioceses with few claims against them could end up heavily subsidising others. There is also wide variance between what different dioceses pay to victims. The average payout from the Dublin diocese is about ?91,000, including costs, while the diocese of Killaloe has paid an average of ?132,000 to two victims, also including costs.

A number of bishops are beginning to consider whether it would be better for each diocese to "go it alone", so only dioceses in difficulties due to abuse claims would get assistance from a central fund.

The trust was set up to accommodate insurance monies from Church & General. Later it was decided to maintain it as a way for the 26 dioceses to show solidarity towards one another.

Even if it is eventually decided to change the basis of the trust, it is likely a smaller sum of money will be paid into it each year, as it is also used to finance the child protection and victim counselling services.

The bishops issued a statement earlier this month announcing a review of the trust is being undertaken. The statement also announced that, to date, 143 claims against 36 priests have been paid out.

David Quinn
Religious Affairs Correspondent


? Irish Independent

Home |About Us |Our Services |Online Resources |Family Tracing |News |Forum |Donate |Contact Us